Tuesday, March 21, 2023

Comparing the 6 Castle Parks - part 1


GENERAL COMPARISON OF THE PARKS



1. DISNEYLAND

OPENED: JULY 17, 1955

Creating a place where adults and children could have fun together. This was Walt Disney’s initial idea, eventually becoming Disneyland. The first plan was a much smaller park adjacent the Disney Studios in Burbank called Mickey Mouse Park. At first the Burbank City Council voted in favor of this park, but as the idea grew bigger, the final proposal was rejected in 1952. The council did not want a dirty amusement park attracting ‘the wrong kind of people’. (After the war, many amusement parks were left neglected like Coney Island for example). So, Walt set out to find a new location and purchased the affordable 160-acre orange tree orchard in Anaheim. At the time, few people believed Disneyland would be successful. It was difficult to convince people that his park would not be an amusement park, but a completely new type of experience: a theme park. It did not help that his park was situated in the middle of nowhere. As was often the case, Walt was right, his park would become a success and it would be the first of many Disney parks around the globe.

Disneyland’s easy-to-understand wheel and spoke lay-out is one of the most genius theme park design elements Walt came up with. Any guest can easily return to the hub at any given time to get orientated and decide which one of the five lands to visit next: Main Street U.S.A., Adventureland, Frontierland, Fantasyland or Tomorrowland. The names are chosen to be clear and simple so guests can assume what is to be found inside each land. In the earliest drawings, the park featured more lands including Holiday Land and Lilliputian Land, but these were scrapped. Holiday Land did open in 1957 and closed 4 years later in 1961.

Over the years four additional lands opened: New Orleans Square in 1966, Bear Country in 1972 (renamed Critter Country in 1988), Mickey’s Toontown in 1993 and finally the Star Wars based Galaxy’s Edge in 2019. Today, Disneyland has 9 themed lands, featuring over 60 attractions, more than any of the other Disney parks.

 


2. MAGIC KINGDOM

OPENED: OCTOBER 1, 1971

When Walt Disney unveiled plans for what was known as “The Florida Project” by insiders, his initial goal was to create a real living city with transportation and design elements way ahead of its time, known as EPCOT: the Experimental Prototype Community of Tomorrow. But after his death in 1966 the Disney company was struggling to create this massive project. Finally, it was Roy Disney, Walt’s brother who led the company to create Walt’s biggest dream anyway. Instead of taking the risk of opening the enormous and expensive EPCOT, they chose to open Magic Kingdom, a safer choice since it was based of the highly successful Disneyland.

The biggest issue was space. Walt was frustrated that he could purchase only 160 acres of land in Anaheim and to his dismay his park became boxed in with cheap hotels and retail spaces popping up around it. That is why The Disney Company secretly bought a total of 27000 acres of land in Florida. This time the surroundings would be filled with Disney’s own choice. A theme park surrounded by themed hotels, recreational areas, lakes and so on. Assured nothing unforeseen might pop, they also kept open spaces or natural elements in-between each location. The theme park itself would also be bigger. The innovative design of Disneyland was perfected in Florida for Magic Kingdom is designed to handle more crowds, with bigger walking paths and more open space. And there would be plenty of room left for expansion.

In the earliest drafts the park featured seven themed lands. The five Disneyland originals: Main Street U.S.A., Adventureland, Frontierland, Fantasyland and Tomorrowland. With Liberty Square, a replacement for New Orleans Square, and Holiday Land added. The latter would be dropped and so Magic Kingdom opened with six themed lands. In 1988, to celebrate Mickey’s 60 Birthday, a special temporary land was added: Mickey’s Birthdayland. Because of its success it became a permanent land, it was renamed Mickey’s Starland in 1990 and Mickey’s Toontown Fair in 1996. It closed eventually in 2011 to make place for the area Storybook Circus in the New Fantasyland, that opened in 2012.

Magic Kingdom opened as a part of the Walt Disney World Resort, together with two hotels, two golf courses and the monorail. Later that year a campground and some key attractions in the park like Peter Pan’s Flight, Submarine Voyage and Flight to the Moon opened.



3. TOKYO DISNEYLAND

OPENED: APRIL 15, 1983

Tokyo Disneyland was the first Disney park to be constructed outside the US and the first to be owned by another company: The Oriental Land Company (OLC), licensing the themes from The Walt Disney Company. It was the OLC that came to Disney with a proposal to build a theme park in Japan. Disney was intrigued and at the same time worried. They questioned the weather and how to adapt the park to the Japanese guests. Furthermore, being occupied with the construction of EPCOT in Florida they said no at first. OLC proved persistent and convinced Disney by assuring the weather would not be a problem if the park was done properly. They also assured that no cultural adaptations were needed, people would come for the simple fact that it was so American. The OLC would finance everything, while Disney would be in control creatively. The deal was signed eventually, and construction began in 1979.

One inspirational painting by Herbert Ryman showed Space Mountain to the left of the castle rather than the typical right side. Interestingly, an early lay-out of the park showed Tomorrowland indeed on this spot and Adventureland and Frontierland on the other side. This plan also introduced a sixth land: International Land, a miniature version Epcot’s World Showcase, not to be confused with World Bazaar. The latter would be a contemporary international shopping and dining street, much bigger than the current version, including entertainment facilities, designed to be able to operate independently of the other lands. For they would close if the weather was bad. Although, these ideas may seem interesting and renewing, OLC made it clear to copy as much as possible from the existing Disneyland and Magic Kingdom parks. The result was a park with clones from the best attractions of both parks. The total cost of the project ran up to 180 billion yen against a budgeted 100 billion yen. OLC’s President Takahashi made it clear to build the real thing without compromises.

The biggest difference in lay-out is the huge hub and the large walking paths throughout the park. There is open space to be found everywhere. This was chosen as a striking difference between the density of Japan, and Tokyo in particular. Guest come to the park for leisure, it had to have a relaxed atmosphere.

On opening day, Tokyo Disneyland consisted of five themed lands: Adventureland, including a small New Orleans area, Westernland, Fantasyland, Tomorrowland, and World Bazaar. The latter resembling Main Street U.S.A., but with a giant canopy over it. Disneyland clones of Critter Country and Toontown were added in 1992 and 1996 respectively.

A change of strategy occurred most notably with the opening of the resort’s second gate: Tokyo DisneySea, a completely unique and extremely detailed park, featuring no cloned attractions whatsoever. Tokyo Disneyland too, would welcome some original attractions and additions including the unique Beauty and the Beast themed expansion of Fantasyland in 2020.

 


4. DISNEYLAND PARIS (opened as EURO DISNEYLAND)

OPENED: APRIL 12, 1992

Remark: although 'Disneyland Park' is the official name of this park and 'Disneyland Paris' is the name of the resort, I will use 'Disneyland Paris' as name of this park to avoid confusion with the original Disneyland Park in Anaheim. 

Disney was interested in opening a park in Europe as early as the seventies. But it was not until the proven success of Tokyo Disneyland and under new management of CEO Michael Eisner, concrete plans were realized. Many countries were considered, but the location near Paris in France was chosen because it was so central in Europe. Some argued Spain would be a better choice for the climate, but Eisner argued that weather was not a problem, given the success of Tokyo even in the rainy winter season. 

Quite opposite to the agreement in Japan, the European agreement stated that the park had to have some tributes to European culture in general and French civilization specifically. Tony Baxter, senior vice president of creative development for the project, said this was certainly a challenge. Disneyland needed to be redefined here for in America there was nothing to compare with, there was no competition. In France, there was history, art, and a landscape that defines ‘charming’ and ‘pastoral’. The park needed to fit in, it had to be typically Disney but mixed with European artistry and heritage.      

Not just the park but the whole complex would be adapted for the European market. Research pointed out that Europeans travelling to the USA showed the most interest in New York, Disneyland, and the western states. The themed hotels: Hotel New York, Hotel Cheyenne, Hotel Santa Fe, Sequoia Lodge, and off course Disneyland Hotel, reflect this interest. On top, a permanent Wild West Show was added in the entertainment complex, Festival Disney.

Euro Disneyland opened with five themed lands, keeping four traditional lands: Main Street U.S.A., Frontierland, Adventureland, and Fantasyland. Discoveryland, was chosen as a replacement for Tomorrowland, it was going to be very French and very European at the same time. The park featured many attractions upon opening, including the ones that were added little by little in the previous parks. The advantage here was that they could be fitted in from scratch, making the overall design of the park quite brilliant.

The park opened with almost 40 attractions, more than any other Disney park on opening day. With 6 hotels, a campground, a golf course and an entertainment complex, the Euro Disney Resort was the biggest of any Disney Resorts upon opening too.

 


5. HONG KONG DISNEYLAND

OPENED: SEPTEMBER 12, 2005

Since Hong Kong has proven to be a good steppingstone for businesses to launch into China and given the ongoing success of the first Asian park in Tokyo, Disney grabbed the opportunity to open a new theme park here. It sits on quite a unique location with beautiful mountains as a natural backdrop for the park and a great view over the South China Sea and the Hong Kong Skyline from the hotels.

Just like in Paris, Disney made sure to build the park respecting the local culture. Therefore, a local Feng Shui master was contacted. His advice was used to adapt the overall masterplan, namely the location and orientation of every structure including the orientation of the park in general. Throughout the park and the hotels many elements are slightly adapted to fit the Feng Shui rules including the use of certain colors and numbers and the implication of the five elements: fire, water, earth, wood and metal. Finally, four symbolic creatures, namely Tortoise, White Tiger, Phoenix and Dragon located in the four cardinal directions in the topiary gardens in front of the park were added.

After the financial struggles of the European park, Disney made sure not to make the mistake again of opening too much too soon. Designed as a homage to the original Disneyland in California, the park opened with only four lands: Main Street U.S.A., Adventureland, Fantasyland, and Tomorrowland. The typical Frontierland was dropped, although it appeared in an early presentation which also included Toontown. Being small, the park lacked many classic rides, especially thrill rides. Many new lands and attractions were added over the years. In 2011 Toy Story Land was added, followed in 2012 by Grizzly Gulch, as an alternative for Frontierland, and finally Mystic Point opened in 2013 as a completely unique land. With these expansions, the park now consists of seven themed lands and two more lands under construction. The first is World of Frozen, opening later this year and the second is Stark Expo set to open in 2024.

Alternative additional lands like a Pirate Land or a land called Glacier Bay were proposed but rejected by the Hong Kong Government who owns the majority of the park.

Hong Kong Disneyland opened on September 12th, 2005, a Feng Shui lucky date. On top of that, it opened to coincide with the 50th birthday of the original Disneyland in Anaheim. On opening day, the resort included two hotels. A third hotel was added later in 2017.



6. SHANGHAI DISNEYLAND

OPENED: JUNE 16, 2016

Opening a Disney theme park on mainland China was a challenge Bob Iger, CEO of the Walt Disney Company, took personal. China is after all the second largest economy of the world, after the U.S.A. To please the Shendi Group, the state-owned Chinese partners, adapting the park and adding as much of the Chinese culture as possible was more than ever a necessity. Disney even invented the slogan: ‘Authentically Disney, Distinctly Chinese’, to underline this.

This park was going to be different, more than just a copy with cultural adaptations, like Paris or Hong Kong, they redesigned the park from scratch. First: The American lands Main Street U.S.A. and Frontierland were left out. Instead, you enter the park through Mickey Avenue, a land with the same function as Main Street, but with a different theme. Frontierland, with all its beloved attractions, was dropped in favor of Treasure Cove, a pirate themed land. Adventureland was renamed Adventure Isle, featuring completely different attractions. Finally, the hub was replaced by an entire new land: Gardens of Imagination. This land features a handful of classic rides in a Chinese looking environment. This implicated the hub-and-spoke design to be scrapped too. It is replaced by a big circular boulevard around the Gardens. Fantasyland and Tomorrowland are the only ‘classic’ lands that remained. Tomorrowland taking the spot on the left side rather than the typical right side of the hub, is one notable change though. Since Paris does not have a Tomorrowland, Fantasyland is the only land present in all of the 6 castle parks.

Instead of an overall circular lay-out, like all previous parks, Shanghai looks more like a Venn diagram. This makes the distances from one land to the other longer but creates calm open spaces. Something missing most notably in the original Disneyland. 

Shanghai features the most unique range of attractions too for many stalwarts were scrapped such as Haunted Mansion, Splash Mountain, and It’s a Small World. Again, this was done to avoid any hint at cultural imperialism. Other classic rides were altered completely. Tomorrowland was designed by Britain-based Grimshaw Architects, making it look entirely different from any previous version. It features a multi leveled land with a freeform canopy over its key attraction: Tron Lightcycle coaster, instead of the classic Space Mountain.

With its 963 acres, the park was marketed as the biggest of any Disney park. One important detail here is that this consists of the entire resort rather than just the park. There exists no official acreage of the park and this is confusing. Some sources state that it is more than 11 times the size of the original Disneyland in Anaheim. A simple measurement of the occupied land proves the theme park by itself is actually quite similar in size.

With its 6 lands Shanghai Disneyland opened on June 16th, 2016. Simultaneously 2 hotels and an entertainment complex known as Disneytown opened. It featured the Mandarin version of the Broadway musical The Lion King. In 2018 Toy Story Land was added as the 7th themed land. City of Zootopia is currently under construction as the park’s 8th land.




(click image to enlarge)

No comments:

Post a Comment